Johnny Mize’s 1939 All-Star Watch | 14K Gold Lord Elgin

Fall Premier Auction · Featured Lot

Johnny Mize's 1939 All-Star 14K Gold Lord Elgin Watch

Presented to Hall of Famer Johnny Mize for his All-Star selections with the St. Louis Cardinals, with his name painted on the dial and "John Mize, All-Star, 1939" engraved on the back, from the year he won the batting title and the home run crown.

Bid Now
Johnny Mize 14K gold Lord Elgin All-Star watch with Johnny Mize and All Star Games 37-39 on the dial
"Johnny Mize" and "All Star Games 37-39" on the silvered Lord Elgin dial.
1939All-StarEngraved on the case back
.349NL Batting Title1939
28Home RunsLed the National League
14KGold Lord ElginRectangular case

Personalized awards from Johnny Mize's playing days rarely reach the market. Offered here is the 14K gold Lord Elgin wristwatch presented to "The Big Cat" in recognition of his All-Star selections with the St. Louis Cardinals, his name painted right on the dial and engraved on the back.

The Big Cat's Best Year

1939 was the finest season of Mize's young career. He won the National League batting title with a .349 average, led the league with 28 home runs and finished runner-up in the NL MVP voting to Cincinnati's Bucky Walters.

.349Batting average, best in the NL
28Home runs, best in the NL
2ndIn 1939 NL MVP voting

A batting title, a home run crown and an All-Star watch with his name on the dial.

It was only the beginning. Mize went on to make ten All-Star teams, lead the league in home runs four times and win five World Series rings with the New York Yankees. The Veterans Committee elected him to the Hall of Fame in 1981.

The Watch

The silvered dial carries "Johnny Mize" in red and blue script beneath the Lord Elgin logo and star, along with the inscription "All Star Games 37-39," commemorating his All-Star selections in St. Louis. Gilt Arabic numerals, gilt hands, a blue-printed chapter ring and a subsidiary seconds register complete the dial.

Angle view of Johnny Mize 1939 All-Star Lord Elgin watch showing 14K gold case and crown
The rectangular 14K yellow gold case.

The back of the case is engraved "John Mize, All-Star, 1939." The watch is fitted with an expandable gold-tone link band and presents in very good condition, its dial attractive and legible.

Case back of Lord Elgin watch engraved John Mize All-Star 1939
"John Mize, All-Star, 1939" on the case back.
Johnny Mize 1939 All-Star gold watch in presentation box
Shown in a presentation box.

The Lot

A superb personalized award for the advanced Cardinals or Hall of Fame collector.

Item
Johnny Mize 1939 All-Star presentational wristwatch
Maker
Lord Elgin · 14K yellow gold case
Dial
"Johnny Mize" · "All Star Games 37-39"
Engraving
"John Mize, All-Star, 1939" on the case back
Band
Expandable gold-tone link
Condition
Very good · dial attractive and legible
Auction
SCP Auctions Fall Premier
Bidding window
Open now · Closes November 15, 2026
Bid Now